Steam · Action · RPG

ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree

ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree Review: Hard Hits and Razor Margins. FromSoftware delivers an intense expansion that tests dodge timing to the limit while pushing melee variety in great directions.

Vance · Jun 22, 2024 · Played 28 hours on PC via Steam with an Xbox controller

Sharp Inputs and Heavy Weight

Controls in Elden Ring always lived or died by how comfortable you are buffering actions, and this expansion doubles down on that discipline. When you step into the Land of Shadow, enemies do not give you room to breathe or wait out your mistakes. Your dodge roll needs to happen on reaction to the startup swing, not when you think the windup looks scary. The full English voice acting and clean interface keep menus out of your way, letting you focus entirely on reading telegraphs.

The new weapon archetypes change the rhythm of standard encounters immediately. I picked up hand-to-hand combat gear early on, switching from standard blade swings to chaining palm strikes and low kicks. The recovery on those strikes is short enough to let you slip out of incoming retaliation, while thrusting shields let you poke directly behind an active guard without sacrificing positional pressure. If you mistime a counter against an aggressive elite, your stamina evaporates instantly.

A melee skirmish against a heavy enemy in the open fields of the Land of Shadow.
A melee skirmish against a heavy enemy in the open fields of the Land of Shadow.

Demanding Boss Routines

The boss fights in these new legacy dungeons demand total focus on your positioning. Many of these opponents run long, sweeping strings that track your character through the air, forcing you to roll toward the danger rather than panic-rolling backward. If you get caught by the tip of a wide cleave, the hit registration is clean, but the damage will take out three-quarters of your health bar in a blink.

Some encounters throw massive visual effects across the screen, and that is where PC performance wobbles. On Steam, when high-particle sorceries and fire bursts fill the arena during multi-hit combos, you feel momentary frame drops that directly mess with your dodge timing. When an enemy gives you barely any room to safely duck under an overhead smash, any visual stutter turns a clean evade into an immediate death screen.

Navigating an intense boss arena filled with area attacks inside a legacy dungeon.
Navigating an intense boss arena filled with area attacks inside a legacy dungeon.

Dense Layouts and Brutal Field Hazards

Outside the massive castles, the Realm of Shadow is structured with a lot of vertical drops, narrow ravines, and sudden ambushes. It is far denser than the base game fields, which cuts down on empty riding and pushes you into tight skirmishes where camera control matters just as much as your weapon reach. You cannot easily sprint past groups because aggressive horn-bearing brutes and lurking caverns monsters will chase you down and clip you off your mount.

The vertical drops mean you spend serious time hunting for switchbacks and hidden spiritspring jumps to reach lower ravines. It creates tense dungeon crawls where you are low on flasks, checking every corner for ceiling drops or lunging beasts before committing to an attack recovery animation. The tension stays high because normal mobs hit hard enough to punish careless running.

The Cost of Survival

At $39.99, this release costs nearly as much as a full standalone title, but the sheer volume of combat content justifies the price tag. You get dense legacy dungeons stacked on top of each other, loaded with brand-new equipment, incantations, and nasty enemy types that force you to rebuild your combat habits. It does not soften the blow for anyone who struggled through the late stages of the base campaign.

Every encounter here is built to catch people rolling early. The tracking on enemy pivot turns can feel absurdly sticky at first glance, but once you memorize where the active damage box actually travels, slipping inside their blind spots feels incredible. It asks for strict execution, and when the hardware holds a steady framerate, the melee combat is some of the most rewarding FromSoftware has ever put together.

A wide vista overlooking the ruins and towering landmarks of the expansion territory.
A wide vista overlooking the ruins and towering landmarks of the expansion territory.

Related reviews

View all ›

Comments 0

BestNewest

No comments yet.