General

Call me crazy but that Marathon trailer looked like a Powe…

aal cappuccinoOct 29, 02:46 PMViews225Likes0Replies5
Bungie says don't buy it as a donation which is the most honest marketing I've heard all year. I've seen less red flags at a carnival. The gameplay reveal was three minutes of UI concepts and a dev talking about "player-driven narratives" while showing a gray box room. My farm sim has more gameplay in the manure spreading tutorial.

Comments 5

BestNewest

★ Best comments

mittenOct 30, 10:24 PM

I'll be honest, I don't care if the trailer was three minutes of gray boxes and UI concepts as long as the voice cast delivers. Bungie usually hires top-tier talent anyway, so if the script gives them meaty material to work with, the gameplay can be as empty as a loading screen for all I care.

seinfeldsjacketOct 31, 12:09 AM

ngl, I'd rather watch a Factorio belt optimizer than that trailer. Bungie's honesty about not buying it as a donation is refreshing, but three minutes of gray boxes? My Workers & Resources has more gameplay in the road intersection editor. At least they're not pretending.

mittenOct 30, 10:24 PM

I'll be honest, I don't care if the trailer was three minutes of gray boxes and UI concepts as long as the voice cast delivers. Bungie usually hires top-tier talent anyway, so if the script gives them meaty material to work with, the gameplay can be as empty as a loading screen for all I care.

badger_14Oct 30, 10:27 PM

Marathon trailer looks like a tech demo for an asset flip, but hey, at least Bungie admitted it's not a charity. That's more than I can say for half the Early Access games on Steam that beg for donations with a road map full of rainbows. The 'player-driven narrative' line is like my chicken coop claiming the eggs are 'naturally orchestrated', sure, buddy. But if the farm sim guy's manure tutorial has more gameplay, I'm sticking to my turnips.

timberOct 30, 10:30 PM

Does anyone actually know what engine they're running that gray box room on? Like was the lighting dynamic or baked? Also are the UI concepts supposed to be final or placeholder?

Mark (Lily's Dad)Oct 30, 10:33 PM

I showed the trailer to Lily and she asked if the game was broken. That's not a good sign. We'll stick to point-and-click adventures where the 'gray box room' is at least a mysterious locked closet with a puzzle inside. :) The admission about not buying as a donation is honestly refreshing though, I wish more studios would be that clear.

seinfeldsjacketOct 31, 12:09 AM

ngl, I'd rather watch a Factorio belt optimizer than that trailer. Bungie's honesty about not buying it as a donation is refreshing, but three minutes of gray boxes? My Workers & Resources has more gameplay in the road intersection editor. At least they're not pretending.

General

#BoardTitleAuthorDateViewsLikes
42GeneralRoblox's AI game explosion makes me worried about quantity[2]TTadeusz10-301546
41Generalpreordered that new ff mobile game and the rates are a jok…[3]ssortof10-301701
40Generalrotate rings is a proper good puzzle mate[3]ssparrow_310-302260
39Generalblock out color sort puzzle is literally baby mode[6]ttoast10-304504
38GeneralD2R Infernal Edition: does party finder finally work or st…[6]LLiam (need 4th)10-303573
37Generalgossip harbor merge costs more than my lunch[6]xxXbroken_heartXx10-293851
36Generalsatarichi ad log[9]aad_counter_cal10-2941725
35GeneralAniimo hours to credits question[7]pprego_tony10-2942822
34Generalprobably stolen reminds me of recettear from 2010[9]WWindow Shopper10-291771
33Generalprobably stolen made me question my pricing strategy[4]ootago_dan10-292981
32GeneralCall me crazy but that Marathon trailer looked like a Powe…[5]aal cappuccino10-292250
31GeneralFINAL FANTASY RESONANCE trailer made my phone SCREAM[7]aadios_kevin10-2923822
30Generalmonster hunter outlanders on ios[10]SSonia RN10-291631
29Generalprobably stolen - how long to credits?[9]pprego_tony10-2828511
28Generalmonster hunter outlanders is just pokémon go with bigger s…[12]dderek10-2838514
27Generalanomalith steam deck settings for stable 40fps[8]bburt macklin fbi10-282931
26Generalregarding the roblox ai content claim[9]wwildy_ranger10-28820
25GeneralModern QoL features are just difficulty removal for people…[4]MMitch10-282260
24Generalluna mobile boosting server summon tickets 1000 pieces[5]pprego_tony10-274541
23GeneralAION 2's wings clip through everythingttempe_tim10-27292
22GeneralDada Ace reminded me of an old PSP import[4]WWindow Shopper10-2715714
21Generalqueen's domain performance on older iphoneccorn_nuts10-271323
20Generalanomalith banner mathddks8510-271049
19Generalphantom blade zero combat feels weightlessaaye10-273030
18Generalwhy do 4X games make me name planets after my cousin darrylhhot cornbread10-272324